From Art to Cheap Carnival Prizes

 

QUESTION: Recently, as I was helping my grandmother to downsize before moving to an assisted living community, I discovered several pieces of kitchy Plaster of Paris figurines, small lamps, and strange little pockets depicting animals with a hollow space behind them. My grandmother told me that my grandfather had won them for her at the annual summer carnival. What are these things? Can you tell me more about their history?

ANSWER: The items belonging to your grandmother are known as chalkware. Though popular during the mid 20th century, chalkware actually got its start in the 18th century as an alternative to Staffordshire ware. But most people recognize it as the cheap carnival prizes given away to winners of games. 

Chalkware is an American term for popular figurines either made of molded plaster of Paris or sculpted gypsum, and painted, typically with oils or watercolors. Often referred to as the "poor man's porcelain," chalkware was primarily created from the late 18th century to the beginning of the 20th century, during the Great Depression, and during the Mid-Century Modern era. Created during the earlier period as a serious decorative art, often imitating the more expensive imported English Staffordshire figurines. Those during the second period were more typically satirical. 

Once it cured or hardened, a worker removed the plaster holder from the mold and painted to give it strong eye appeal. Chalkware became a popular item sold in five and dime stores, and the designs seemed endless. Most manufacturers, including Roseville, Weller, and McCoy potteries, produced a variety of wall pockets, designed to hang on the wall and hold a variety of items, such as stamps, matches, flowers, and letters. 

As the Great Depression took hold in the U.S. in the 1930s, chalkware shifted towards more whimsical designs. These items were both colorful and playful, providing a brief escape from the economic woes of the time.

Eventually, carnival operators begin giving chalkware figures as prizes, especially during World War II. By the 1960s, stuffed animals replaced them.

After the War, young homeowners sought out chalkware as an inexpensive and expressive decor for their homes, including table lamps, figurines, and wall decor. Attracting fine, mundane and comic artists, chalkware reached a broad audience from 1945 to 1965, providing everything from representations of European sculpture, to kitsch images of exotic travel and cartoonish characters.

By the mid 1950s in the United Kingdom, chalkware took the form of eggcups, match holders, and ashtrays. The earliest designers were Paoli Brothers and Hermann Lohnberg. By 1956, tastes changed with a move to animals. By 1957, figurines and statues of African-style ladies and gentlemen had become popular.  

Mid 20th century chalkware lamps were often romantic and exotic with a focus on the idealized beauty of historic, natural, and abstract designs. Common motifs included dancers, often sold as a male and female pair, innocent or sensual figures, trees, flowers, animals, zig-zags, waves and modern abstract sculpture typical of the period. One of the most popular motifs were of romanticized, stereotyped Asian, African, Native American, Hawaiian people in exotic and often inaccurate settings or costumes. Some of these lamps were made as nightlights with small bulbs. TV lamps, based upon popular chalkware radio lamp designs, quickly became replaced by ceramic.

Wall decor chalkware included bath motifs like fish or mermaids, kitchen motifs like fruit, and 'wall pockets' that often were faces with small areas in the back suitable for air plants or plastic flowers.

People took to the highways in the booming post-war era, creating a need for tourist souvenirs, including ashtrays, figures, bobble-heads and destination-specific items. 

One of the overlooked markets for chalkware was the religious-based one. Manufacturers produced a large variety of statuary, wall plaques, and other religious objects for use in churches and the home. 

Some of the more popular American chalkware companies include Continental Art Company and Universal Statuary Corporation in Chicago, Alexander Baker Company and 'ABCO' in New York, Fine Arts In Plastics or F.A.I.P in Brooklyn, Jo Wallis Lamp Company, Miller Studios, and Reglor in  California, and Vaillancourt Folk Art in Massachusetts.

As the 1970s dawned, heavy, and easy to break or chip, chalkware eventually lost favor to ceramic and plastic alternatives in the 1970s. 

To read more articles on antiques, please visit the Antiques Articles section of my Web site.  And to stay up to the minute on antiques and collectibles, please join the over 50,000 readers by following my free online magazine, #TheAntiquesAlmanac. Learn more about "Federal America" in the 2026 Spring Edition, online now. And to read daily posts about unique objects from the past and their histories, like the #Antiques and More Collection on Facebook.

Stringing Along

QUESTION: I like to browse thrift shops. There are several in my area in which I’ve found some unique antiques and collectibles. One of the most unusual has been the string holder. This kitchy item has an almost comic character. I’ve purchased several over the last few years but know practically nothing about them. Can you tell me how string holders originated and how long they were made?

ANSWER: String has been a common item in homes and businesses for a long time. But string can easily get tangled, so inventors came up with ways to keep string in line. During the 19th century, the traditional shape of cast-iron string holders was the beehive. Others were egg-shaped  with openings around their sides so storekeepers could see how much string was left.

People often associate string holders with general stores, when storekeepers wrapped purchases in brown paper dispensed from a roll mounted on a frame with a cutting bar. Then, the storekeeper secured the package with string or twine. The wrapping paper generally sat on its frame at the end of the counter, and the string holder was suspended from the ceiling right over the. counter. Some of these holders were elaborate, complete with a sign promoting some product, such as Heinz pickles. Others, were simply a cast iron hole tin frame that held a ball or cone of twine and fed the string through a hole in the bottom.




By the early 20th century string holders had come into the home. These were usually figural pieces that hung on the wall and had a compartment to hold a ball of string. A person could feed the string through a hole in the figure, typically through the mouth in  a face, where it could be pulled out for a given amount, then cut off for use. While some of the early examples date to the 19th century, these decorative figures became popular from the start of the Great Depression through the 1950s. Manufacturers produced string holders from a variety of materials, including cast-iron, wood, glass, and porcelain, but the predominant choice of material was chalkware, more commonly known as plaster of paris. Many string holder manufacturers used it because of its low cost and ease in which it could be cast.

Once it cured or hardened, workers removed the plaster holder from the mold and painted to give it strong eye appeal. It was a popular item sold in five and dime stores, and the designs seemed to be endless. More often than not, manufacturers produced a broad line of wall pockets, of which string holders were one of the line. Wall pockets were designed to hang on the wall and hold a variety of items, such as stamps, matches, flowers, letters, etc. Some of the better known manufacturers of`wall pockets and string holders include McCoy, Roseville, Weller, and other established firms.

One of the companies that produced unique string holders was Miller Studio of New Philadelphia, Ohio. Miller Studio made string holders from 1947 to 1958. Some of their early designs included Jo-Jo the Clown, a wormy apple that featured "Willie the Worm, Susie Sunfish, and a kitten on a red ball of yarn. In 1949 they dropped the clown and sunfish and added "Miss Strawberry" and "Little Chef." In 1952, Miller replaced “Little Chef” with "Prince Pineapple." Then a year later, Miller dropped “Prince Pineapple,” replacing him with "Posie Pig." Because of its short time on the market, “Posie Pig” is the most difficult to find today.

String holders came in a large variety of shapes and designs. Most collectors focus their collections on a single category. Fruits and vegetables have always been a popular design for producers. Collectors can find everything from apples and bananas to green peppers and pineapples to hang on the kitchen wall. Animals have always been a top selling category, from cats and dogs to birds of every description.

While the cartoon characters and animals have always been popular with collectors of string holders, some choose to focus their collections on people designs, which include black memorabilia,  girls and women, fairy tale figures, boys and men, chefs, clowns, and comic cartoon characters.

Another category popular with col tors are designs featuring cartoon characters or advertising icons, including Elsie the Borden Cow, the Coca Cola Kid, Aunt Jemima, Smokey the Bear, Popeye, Shirley Temple, Betty Boop, and a rare 1940s Mickey Mouse.




But beware of the many reproductions and fantasy string holders currently for sale online. This is especially true in the category of black memorabilia where many of the figures of chefs, mammys and other black character figures are being copied in off-shore facilities and are flooding the marketplace. Don't confuse these reproductions with the new limited editions crafted by various artists and sold as new.

To read more articles on antiques, please visit the Antiques Article section of my site.  And to stay up to the minute on antiques and collectibles, please join the other 18,000 readers by following my free online magazine, #TheAntiquesAlmanac. Learn more about the Victorians in the Winter 2018 Edition, "All Things Victorian," online now.